The part about Claude guessing instead of asking is the real tell for me. I've found the skills that work best aren't the ones with the cleverest prompts, they're the ones that explicitly instruct Claude to stop and ask a clarifying question before it starts. Most people write skills for the task and forget to write skills for the uncertainty.
Worth opening the SKILL.md before you hit Save. It's plain markdown that Claude follows like your own instructions, so a lookalike copy only needs one extra line to send it somewhere you never asked for.
Useful list. The folder is the expertise, written down once. And the test for when to build your own is simple. Same task, same way, more than twice, write it down once.
Testing 23 skills is a strong filter, since most viral lists never say what failed. Which skill saved the most time in a real task, and which one looked good but did not hold up?
On /handoff, add a line for what you already tried and ruled out. Without it the fresh chat happily re-proposes the dead ends.
The part about Claude guessing instead of asking is the real tell for me. I've found the skills that work best aren't the ones with the cleverest prompts, they're the ones that explicitly instruct Claude to stop and ask a clarifying question before it starts. Most people write skills for the task and forget to write skills for the uncertainty.
Worth opening the SKILL.md before you hit Save. It's plain markdown that Claude follows like your own instructions, so a lookalike copy only needs one extra line to send it somewhere you never asked for.
Useful list. The folder is the expertise, written down once. And the test for when to build your own is simple. Same task, same way, more than twice, write it down once.
Testing 23 skills is a strong filter, since most viral lists never say what failed. Which skill saved the most time in a real task, and which one looked good but did not hold up?